
Georgia Power has started a new Smart Energy Program, offering an online questionnaire about your energy use at home. The idea is to help you save money by analyzing your energy usage for ways to save, but our initial reaction is that the result is much less than it could be.
The questionnaire asks many questions about your house: the size, the age, the number of rooms, the kind and age of your air conditioner and heater, the kind and age of your water heater, what kind of thermostat you have, what temperatures you set it for during the summer and winter, and then moves on to your washer and dryer, your refrigerator, dishwasher, and oven. It takes about 15 minutes to complete, pulls your monthly electricity use from your power bills, and generates a downloadable PDF report.
When you get the report, the first thing you notice is that the report ignores everything in your house that doesn’t use electricity. So, in our case, there was no information on the energy usage of our furnace, our water heater, or our oven. Well, perhaps that shouldn’t be surprising given that this report is sponsored by the power company.
It lists your monthly power consumption for 2009 and 2010 in a side-by-side format. It then charts your monthly power usage for 2008-2010 against the average temperature for your area — not the actual temperature for that individual month and year, but the average temperature generally for that month over many years (see below).
And that illustrates the biggest problem with this report: everything is based on vague averages. Your breakdown of power usage is based on national averages, not on your actual use. That doesn’t tell you much about how your behavior should change, or what you may need to upgrade.
The report closes with a sales pitch for the Marathon water heater that Georgia Power offers for sale and a series of generic suggestions for saving energy. There’s also a chart showing how Georgia Power’s rates have increased less than the national rates for natural gas, propane, gasoline, and other sources of energy. Again, nothing specific.
I hate to rain on Georgia Power’s parade. Any steps in this direction should be encouraged. But their report does not begin to offer the kind of guidance that would actually help homeowners figure out ways to save money. By the last page it’s turned into a public relations piece that won’t help you save money.
It makes our humble Greening Neighborhoods weekly tips look just that much better.